5960 Old Mill Rd NE, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110
Welcome to this sunlit haven on historic Old Mill Road. Nestled on 1.74 level acres with fruit trees, expansive lawn, and a wrap-around porch, this Bainbridge Island retreat blends timeless charm with flexible living. Just moments from Blakely Elementary, Winslow, and miles of scenic trails, it’s a rare opportunity to enjoy both space and convenience in one exceptional setting.
Presented at: $
5960 Old Mill Rd NE, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110
Welcome to this sunlit haven on historic Old Mill Road. Nestled on 1.74 level acres with fruit trees, expansive lawn, and a wrap-around porch, this Bainbridge Island retreat blends timeless charm with flexible living. Just moments from Blakely Elementary, Winslow, and miles of scenic trails, it’s a rare opportunity to enjoy both space and convenience in one exceptional setting.
Presented at: $
The Home
Inside, the residence unfolds with a flexible and inviting floor plan. The main level features an eat-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances, a welcoming family room, formal dining, and a living room enhanced by white tongue-and-groove ceilings for a touch of coastal charm. Upstairs, three comfortable bedrooms plus a bonus room/office provide ample space for both relaxation and productivity.
Property & Location
Set on an expansive 1.74-acre level lot, this property offers the rare combination of open lawn, mature fruit trees, and abundant space to garden, play, or simply enjoy the soundtrack of birdsong. A gracious wrap-around covered porch, oriented west and southwest, provides the perfect setting to bask in golden afternoon light and savor outdoor living year-round.
Thoughtful outbuildings add opportunities for storage, creative studio space, or hobbies. Beyond the property, the lifestyle is unmatched—just down the road from award-winning Blakely Elementary, close to Winslow’s amenities, and steps from an extensive trail system that winds through Bainbridge’s natural beauty.

Property Details
- 2,091 sqft
- 3 bedrooms + office
- 2.5 bathrooms
- 1.740 acres
- 2-Car Garage
- Year Built: 1991
- Outbuildings for storage or studio
- Community: Eagle Harbor
- MLS#2434856